{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":4,"sheets":["Instructions","Applicant Input","IB-12 Targets","DropDownLists"],"not_rendered":{"charts":0,"images":4,"macros":1,"external_links":1,"defined_names":3,"comments":1,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Instructions","index":0,"n_rows":32,"n_cols":2,"rows_kept":32,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,0,0,11],[31,0,36,0],[13,1,18,11],[1,1,6,11],[7,1,12,11],[19,1,24,11],[25,1,30,11],[31,1,36,11],[13,0,18,0],[19,0,24,0],[25,0,30,0],[1,0,6,0],[7,0,12,0]]}
["INSTRUCTIONS:"]
[1,"Select applicable highlighted cell in the \"Performance Target Achieved\" column and choose the appropriate score in the dropdown menu according to the \"Available Performance Targets\" column description. Please note that only one score can be selected per cell. To clear the cell if the incorrect score has been chosen, select the applicable cell dropdown menu and choose the blank line to start again."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[2,"The \"Points Awarded\" column will show an automatic tally based on the performance target selected. This score is consistent with the associated Sustainability Metrics Program Guidebook document. Please refer to the \"Final Score\" cell at the top and bottom of the spreadsheet to determine the total points awarded."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[3,"Select applicable highlighted cell in the \"Verification Document\" column and choose the appropriate documents that display and provides rationale on the anticipated performance target. The listed verification documents are consistent with the associated Sustainability Metrics Program Guidebook document. Please note that multiple verification documents can be selected within this cell. To clear the cell if the incorrect document has been chosen, select the applicable cell dropdown menu and choose the blank line to start again."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[4,"Applicants can provide additional information in the \"Comments\" column by selecting the applicable cell. Additional information can include: reference to selected verification document, verification document page number, rationale for selection, and/or the name of the chosen \"Other\" document if selected."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[5,"Once the document is complete and the minimum Bronze Performance Level has been achieved, the Excel file can be sent to the City File Planner for review prior to formal submission."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[6,"Once the document has been reviewed and a Bronze Performance Level has been verified by City Staff, the Excel file can be uploaded to ePLAN under the \"Planning - Documents\" folder. Please also include the completed Sustainability Checklist on the draft plan of subdivision drawing."]

{"sheet":"Applicant Input","index":1,"n_rows":101,"n_cols":24,"rows_kept":101,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[96,23,97,23],[17,2,22,2],[24,2,27,2],[28,2,30,2],[48,2,50,2],[55,2,59,2],[82,23,83,23],[84,23,89,23],[90,23,91,23],[92,23,94,23],[63,23,64,23],[65,23,67,23],[68,23,69,23],[72,23,75,23],[37,16,39,16],[32,16,34,16],[51,2,52,2],[68,2,69,2],[90,18,91,18],[90,19,91,19],[79,18,81,18],[79,19,81,19],[60,19,61,19],[90,22,91,22],[65,19,67,19],[32,19,34,19],[14,21,15,21],[18,19,20,19],[21,19,22,19],[14,16,15,16],[14,19,15,19],[14,18,15,18],[14,20,15,20],[18,20,20,20],[21,20,22,20],[32,20,34,20],[43,19,44,19],[37,19,39,19],[35,16,36,16],[21,18,22,18],[18,17,20,17],[48,18,49,18],[14,23,15,23],[17,23,22,23],[24,23,27,23],[28,23,30,23],[32,23,34,23],[35,23,36,23],[18,18,20,18],[43,22,44,22],[37,23,39,23],[43,23,44,23],[68,19,69,19],[68,1,69,1],[68,16,69,16],[63,16,64,16],[63,17,64,17],[63,18,64,18],[18,1,20,1],[21,1,22,1],[32,1,34,1],[60,1,61,1],[35,18,36,18],[37,17,39,17],[37,18,39,18],[48,1,49,1],[51,1,52,1],[46,2,47,2],[68,17,69,17],[65,17,67,17],[65,18,67,18],[63,19,64,19],[65,16,67,16],[46,1,47,1],[68,18,69,18],[18,16,20,16],[14,0,15,0],[14,1,15,1],[14,2,15,2],[17,0,22,0],[24,0,27,0],[28,0,30,0],[60,2,61,2],[63,2,64,2],[14,17,15,17],[21,16,22,16],[21,17,22,17],[35,17,36,17],[32,17,34,17],[63,1,64,1],[43,1,44,1],[43,16,44,16],[37,1,39,1],[65,2,67,2],[51,0,52,0],[53,0,54,0],[55,0,59,0],[60,0,61,0],[63,0,64,0],[65,0,67,0],[32,18,34,18],[65,1,67,1],[32,0,34,0],[35,0,36,0],[37,0,39,0],[43,0,44,0],[46,0,47,0],[48,0,50,0],[43,2,44,2],[53,16,54,16],[43,17,44,17],[46,17,47,17],[48,17,49,17],[68,0,69,0],[35,1,36,1],[53,1,54,1],[14,22,15,22],[18,22,20,22],[21,22,22,22],[28,22,29,22],[32,22,34,22],[37,22,39,22],[37,2,39,2],[35,2,36,2],[32,2,34,2],[51,16,52,16],[51,17,52,17],[51,18,52,18],[51,19,52,19],[53,17,54,17],[53,18,54,18],[46,16,47,16],[53,19,54,19],[35,19,36,19],[46,19,47,19],[48,16,49,16],[53,2,54,2],[90,20,91,20],[96,0,97,0],[72,0,75,0],[77,0,81,0],[82,0,83,0],[84,0,89,0],[90,0,91,0],[92,0,94,0],[90,16,91,16],[90,17,91,17],[90,1,91,1],[79,1,81,1],[79,16,81,16],[79,17,81,17],[77,2,81,2],[77,1,78,1],[87,2,89,2],[96,2,97,2],[82,2,83,2],[84,2,86,2],[92,2,94,2],[90,2,91,2],[72,2,75,2],[2,1,4,1],[2,2,4,16],[2,18,4,19],[2,20,4,23],[6,1,8,1],[6,2,8,16],[6,18,8,23],[77,23,81,23],[35,20,36,20],[37,20,39,20],[43,20,44,20],[46,20,47,20],[51,20,52,20],[53,20,54,20],[60,20,61,20],[53,22,54,22],[51,22,52,22],[60,16,61,16],[60,17,61,17],[60,18,61,18],[63,20,64,20],[65,20,67,20],[43,18,44,18],[46,18,47,18],[46,23,47,23],[48,23,50,23],[51,23,52,23],[53,23,54,23],[68,20,69,20],[79,20,81,20],[55,23,59,23],[60,23,61,23],[63,22,64,22],[65,22,67,22],[68,22,69,22]]}
[]
[]
[null,"PROPERTY ADDRESS","(ADDRESS HERE)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"DATE OF EXCEL SPREADSHEET COMPLETION",null,"(DATE HERE)"]
[]
[]
[]
[null,"CITY FILE NUMBER","(FILE NUMBER HERE)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"FOR DRAFT PLAN OF SUBDIVISION APPLICATION ONLY"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
["CITY OF MARKHAM SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT TOOL (SCORING TOOL)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Final Score:",{"$f":"SUM(S14:S100)","v":0}]
["INDICATOR #","INDICATOR TITLE","INDICATOR DESCRIPTION","Qualifier","Qualifier question","OBC/Not OBC","Residential only","Mixed-Use","Indus/Comm/Inst only","Block Plan","Draft Plan","Site Plan","Level","Points","Points Achieved","Metric Grouping (Metrics that are related, yellow highlighted cells are metrics that are mutually exclusive - red highlighted are metrics where applicants can get anywhere up to that number)","AVAILABLE PERFORMANCE TARGETS","PERFORMANCE TARGET ACHIEVED"," POINTS AWARDED","VERIFICATION DOCUMENT","LETTER OF COMMITMENT","Verification Staff","NOTES","COMMENTS"]
["BUILT ENVIRONMENT"]
["BE-1","Proximity to Amenities","To encourage development within and near existing amenities, create more walkable communities, and reduce auto dependency.","No",null,"Not OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group A","Good\n• Three or more amenities are within 800 metres (equivalent to a 10 minute walk) of 75% of dwelling units. \n\nGreat\n• Three or more amenities are within 400 metres (equivalent to a 5 minute walk) of 75% of dwelling units.",null,{"$f":"IF(R15=\"Good\",1,IF(R15=\"Great\",3,0))","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","References-"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group A"]
["BE-2","Mixed-Use Development","To support locating housing,\nservices, recreation, schools, shopping, jobs, work space, and other amenities on the same lot or block to facilitate wise use of land, make it easier for people to walk or cycle to these destinations, and reduce auto dependency.","Yes",null,"Not OBC","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group B","Good\n• Where it does not conflict with and is not already a requirement set out in the local Official Plan, Regional Official Plan, or Provincial \n   Plan or policy, a mix of uses is provided on the same lot or block.",null,{"$f":"IF(R17=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Development Planner","this should be a qualifier metric. How to handle this question where mixed use is not supported/feasible?\n-screen it so it only applies to mixed used column and not residential"]
["BE-3","Housing Diversity-Ownership\n(1st of 3 categories for available points)","To encourage a range of housing options and facilitate aging in place.","No",null,"Not OBC","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group C","Good\n• At least 10% of affordable/low income or purpose-built rental housing is provided.",null,{"$f":"IF(R18=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Development Planner"]
[null,"Housing Diversity- Housing Type\n(2nd of 3 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,"Not OBC","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group D","Good\n• Two of the housing typologies listed are provided: Single Detached, Semi Detached, Townhouse, Mid-rise, High-rise, and/or additional \n   dwelling unit within a single detached, semi detached or townhouse dwelling (e.g. second unit, secondary suite).\n\nGreat\n• Three of the housing typologies listed are provided: Single Detached, Semi Detached, Townhouse, Mid-rise, High-rise, and/or \n   additional dwelling unit within a single detached, semi detached or townhouse dwelling (e.g. second unit, secondary suite).\n\nExcellent\n• Four or more of the housing typologies listed are provided: Single Detached, Semi Detached, Townhouse, Mid-rise, High-rise, and/or \n   additional dwelling unit within a single detached, semi detached or townhouse dwelling (e.g. second unit, secondary suite).",null,{"$f":"IF(R19=\"Good\",1,IF(R19=\"Great\",2,IF(R19=\"Excellent\",3,0)))","v":0},null,"No","Development Planner","have this as metric but not as mandatory; or just upgrade it to  great metric so it is not mandatory;\nremove mid and high rise development; only apply to low rise;\nexempt appplications at grade with retail facing along street frontage"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",1,null,"Group D",null,null,null,null,null,"Development Planner"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Excellent",1,null,"Group D",null,null,null,null,null,"Development Planner"]
[null,"Housing Diversity - Accommodation\n(3rd of 3 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group E","Good\n• Two accommodation types are provided: Live-work, Purpose-Built Rental, Studio, 1 bedroom, and/or 2 or more bedrooms.\n\nGreat\n• Three or more accommodation types are provided:  Live-work, Purpose-Built Rental, Studio, 1 bedroom, and/or 2 or more bedrooms.",null,{"$f":"IF(R22=\"Good\",1,IF(R22=\"Great\",2,0))","v":0},null,"No","Development Planner","not every development is appropriate for this"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",1,null,"Group E",null,null,null,null,null,"Development Planner"]
["BE-4","Community and Neighbourhood Scale","To focus on retail, personal, and community services within community core areas (neighbourhood centre and mixed-use node) so that people can meet their daily needs within their communities. ","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","No","Excellent",3,null,"Group F","Excellent\n• New community areas shall be designed to contain community core areas, which will be the focus of retail, personal services, human \n   services, community services and provide connections to rapid transit. The community cores shall be within a reasonable walking \n   distance from the majority of the population.",null,{"$f":"IF(R24=\"Excellent\",3,0)","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","Modified in Guidebook for Markham"]
["BE-5","Cultural Heritage Conservation\n(1st of 4 categories for available points)","To conserve cultural heritage resources, including built heritage resources (listed or designated), cultural heritage landscapes (listed or designated), and archaeological resources.","Yes","Does your site contain a cultural heritage resource?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group J","Good\n• Where a cultural heritage resource will be relocated, it will be moved to a visually prominent location within the subject development site.",null,{"$f":"IF(R25=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Heritage Planner"]
[null,"Cultural Heritage Conservation\n(2nd of 4 categories for available points)",null,"Yes","Does your site contain a cultural heritage resource?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group K","Good\n• Where reusable materials from a cultural heritage resource are being removed, a portion will be salvaged and reused on site.",null,{"$f":"IF(R26=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Heritage Planner"]
[null,"Cultural Heritage Conservation\n(3rd of 4 categories for available points)",null,"Yes","Does your site contain a cultural heritage resource?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group I","Great\n• A portion of the cultural heritage resource is retained, and the integrity of the cultural heritage resource is conserved. ",null,{"$f":"IF(R27=\"Great\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Heritage Planner"]
[null,"Cultural Heritage Conservation\n(4th of 4 categories for available points)",null,"Yes","Does your site contain a cultural heritage resource?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Excellent",3,null,"Group H","Excellent\n• The cultural heritage resource is conserved, and no elements that contribute to its cultural heritage value are demolished, removed, or \n   relocated (excluding temporary removal for restoration purposes).",null,{"$f":"IF(R28=\"Excellent\",3,0)","v":0},null,"No","Heritage Planner","Need confirmation from partners of how to interperet cultural heritage resources. Assume Group H and Group I should be merged (i.e. choose Great or Excellent), and Group J and Group K are additional points."]
["BE-10","Electric Vehicle Charging Stations\n(Non-residential uses)","To facilitate the use of electric vehicles.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",3,null,"Group T","Good\n• Electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) is provided to serve 10% of parking spaces.\n\nGreat\n• Electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) is provided to serve 20% of parking spaces.",null,{"$f":"IF(R29=\"Good\",3,IF(R29=\"Great\",5,0))","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist","Distinguished res from non-res\npreference for providing rough-ins? In projects with structued parking. Don't know which parking spaces will have EV vehicles. Parkiing spaces are owned and purchased so better to provide flexibility of where owners can install charging equipment\nLowrise residential also require for rough-ins for all units vs chargin for only limited number. Don't know which units will have EVs/\nICIs for charging stations?\nCheck Transportation comments"]
[null,"Electric Vehicle Charging Stations\n(Residential mid- and high-rise)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group T","Good\n• For mid-rise and high-rise residential uses with shared parking areas, at least 50% of the parking spaces are designed and constructed \n   to permit future EVSE installation (e.g. rough-in).\n\nExcellent\n• For mid-rise and high-rise residential uses with shared parking areas, 100% of the parking spaces are designed and constructed to \n   permit future EVSE installation (e.g. rough-in).",null,{"$f":"IF(R30=\"Good\",2,IF(R30=\"Excellent\",5,0))","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
[null,"Electric Vehicle Charging Stations\n(Low rise residential)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Excellent",2,null,"Group U","Excellent\n• For low-rise residential with dedicated parking in a private garage, 100% of the parking spaces are designed and constructed to permit \n   future EVSE installation (e.g. rough in).",null,{"$f":"IF(R31=\"Excellent\",5,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist","For purposes of the Scoring Tool, need to separate scoring for (1) mid and high rise, (2) low rise, and (3) non-residential uses."]
["MOBILITY"]
["M-1","Block Length ","To develop shorter blocks that increase permeability offering pedestrians and cyclists multiple routes to reach their destination(s) and to allow blocks with the flexibility to accommodate both residential and commercial lot sizes. Walkable blocks improve connectivity and reduce dependence on vehicles.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Good",1,null,"Group V","Good\n• 75% of block lengths do not exceed 200 metres.\n\nGreat\n• All block lengths do not exceed 200 metres.\n\nExcellent\n• All blocks do not exceed 80 metres x 150 metres in size. ",null,{"$f":"IF(R33=\"Good\",1,IF(R33=\"Great\",2,IF(R33=\"Excellent\",3,0)))","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","Guidebook refers to 200 metre block lengths"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Great",1,null,"Group V",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Excellent",1,null,"Group V",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer"]
["M-2","School Proximity to Transit Routes, Cycling Network, and Walkways","To encourage students to walk and/or cycle to school to reduce vehicle use, traffic congestion at school sites, and promote active transportation. Walking, cycling, and transit use result in GHG emission savings and less air pollution. Walking and cycle also provide health benefits.","Yes","Does your proposal include a school?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Good",1,null,"Group W","Good\n• All existing or planned public schools are located within a 400 metre walking distance to transit routes and/or dedicated cycle network.\n\nGreat\n• All existing or planned public schools are located within a 200 metre walking distance to transit routes and/or dedicated cycle network.",null,{"$f":"IF(R36=\"Good\",1,IF(R36=\"Great\",2,0))","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","Why site plan does not apply to this requirement?"]
[null,null,null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Great",1,null,"Group W",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer","If there is a school within walking distance of 200m for a site plan application, doesn't it qualify?"]
["M-3","Intersection Density ","To encourage shorter blocks and increase permeability and connectivity offering pedestrians and cyclists multiple routes to reach their destination(s). Walkable blocks improve connectivity and reduce dependence on vehicles.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Good",1,null,"Group X","Good\n• Provide for 40-50 multi-use trail, path, and/or street intersections per square kilometre.\n\nGreat\n• Provide for 51-60 multi-use trail, path, and/or street intersections per square kilometre.\n\nExcellent\n• Provide for more than 61 multi-use trail, path, and/or street intersections per square kilometre.",null,{"$f":"IF(R38=\"Good\",1,IF(R38=\"Great\",2,IF(R38=\"Excellent\",4,0)))","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Great",1,null,"Group X",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Excellent",2,null,"Group X",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer"]
["M-4","Promote Walkable Streets","To encourage walking through the provision of safe and comfortable street environments. Walkable streets reduce the dependence on vehicles, improve safety, enhance connectivity, and are an important component for healthy and complete communities.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group Y","Good (Site Plans)\n• For site plans, provide/ extend /upgrade continuous sidewalks or multi-use trails on public streets where supported by the municipality. \n   Points do not apply where an existing sidewalk will remain. \n\nGood (Plans of Subdivision)\n • Provide/extend continuous sidewalks or multi-use trails on both sides of public streets where supported by the municipality.",null,{"$f":"IF(R41=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","Qualifer Metric - need to filter out applications where sidewalks are mandatory\n-also many applications only control on side of street, so maybe make it specifc only to subdivisions?"]
["M-7","Implementing Trails and Cycling Infrastructure","To implement pedestrian and cycling infrastructure to further promote active forms of transportation. Walking and cycling results in GHG emissions savings and less air pollution. Active transportation also provides health benefits.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group DD","Good\n• Implement the objectives of the applicable municipal Active Transportation Master Plan and/or Trails/Pathways Master Plan by \n   implementing the improvements as part of the development.",null,{"$f":"IF(R42=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Transportation Planner / Traffic Planning Technologist","Add qualifier Metric. Review ATP for any objectives that may be achievable for sites without any infrastructure"]
["M-8","Active Transportation Network","To promote active transportation through the provision of public multi-purpose trails/paths and cycling infrastructures. Cycling results in carbon savings and less air pollution. It also provides health benefits.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group EE","Good\n100% of residents/jobs are within 400 metres of:\n• An existing public multi-use trail or cycling infrastructure; or \n• A municipally approved public multi-use trail or cycling infrastructure (identified in a Council approved trail/cycling master plan, but not \n  yet constructed); or\n• A proposed public multi-use trail or cycling infrastructure that is proposed within the development.",null,{"$f":"IF(R43=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Transportation Planner / Traffic Planning Technologist"]
["M-9","Distance to Public Transit","To promote and support alternative transportation modes to personal automotive vehicle use. Transit-oriented communities reduce vehicle-kilometres traveled and associated emissions, have reduced traffic casualty rates and support walking and cycling which improves community health.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group FF","Good\n• The site is within 800 metres walking distance to an existing or planned commuter rail, light rail, bus rapid transit or subway with frequent \n   service.\nOR\n• The site is within 400 metres walking distance to 1 or more existing or planned bus stops with frequent service.\n\nGreat\n• The site is within 400 metres walking distance to an existing or planned commuter rail, light rail, bus rapid transit, or subway with frequent \n   service.\nOR\n• The site is within 200 metre walking distance to 1 or more bus stops with frequent service.",null,{"$f":"IF(R44=\"Good\",1,IF(R44=\"Great\",2,0))","v":0},null,"No","Transportation Planner / Traffic Planning Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",1,null,"Group FF",null,null,null,null,null,"Transportation Planner / Traffic Planning Technologist"]
["NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND OPEN SPACE"]
["NE-1","Tree Conservation","To support the conservation of healthy mature trees and the associated ecological, economic, and healthy benefits. Preserving trees can be a cost-effective method to improve the overall appearance of a community while providing ecological and climate change benefits.","Yes","Does your site contain existing trees?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",3,null,"Group II","Good\n• Preserve 25% of mature trees with a DBH ≥20 centimetres in situ on site.\n\nGreat\n• Preserve 50% of mature trees with a DBH ≥20 centimetres in situ on site or preserve 100% of healthy hedgerows in situ on site.",null,{"$f":"IF(R47=\"Good\",3,IF(R47=\"Great\",5,0))","v":0},null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist","Some sites will not be able to achieve depending on location of trees (e.g if only 3 trees and they are all in the middle of a small site)"]
[null,null,null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group II",null,null,null,null,null,"Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["NE-2","Soil Quantity and Quality for New Trees\n(1st of 2 categories for available points)","To provide soil quantity and quality that enables new trees to thrive. Higher amounts of good quality soil help ensure the success of vegetation.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group JJ","Good\n• Provide a minimum of 30 cubic metres of soil for each new tree and a minimum of 1 metre of uncompact soil depth. \n• Where there is a grouping of trees, provide a minimum of 20 cubic metres of soil for each new tree, and a minimum of 1 metre of \n   uncompact soil depth, or equivalent municipal standard.\n\nGreat\n• Provide 25% more than the total soil volume required by municipal standards. ",null,{"$f":"IF(R49=\"Good\",2,IF(R49=\"Great\",4,0))","v":0},null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist","for large canopy trees (leave it for UD to interpret)"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group JJ",null,null,null,null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
[null,"Soil Quantity and Quality for New Trees\n(2nd of 2 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Excellent",2,null,"Group KK","Excellent\n• Provide uncompact topsoil layer of tree pits, trenches, or planting beds with the following properties:\n     • Organic matter content of 10 to 15% by dry weight and a pH of 6.0 to 8.0.\n     • A minimum depth of 1 metre, or in accordance with municipal standards, whichever is higher.\n     • Provide adequate drainage.",null,{"$f":"IF(R51=\"Excellent\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["NE-3","Healthy Soils","To ensure that new development contains healthy soil quality and quantity to help restore the natural functions of soils and vegetation to help ensure the soil is appropriate for the proposed plantings. Limiting disturbance of healthy soil horizons and maintain soil structure, as well as to support biological communities (above-ground and below-ground).","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group LL","Great\n• A minimum topsoil depth of 300 millimetres is provided across the entire site (excluding paved surfaces).",null,{"$f":"IF(R52=\"Great\",2,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist","Good target no applicable to Markham as it is below municipal standards. Only Great target applies."]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",1,null,"Group LL",null,null,null,null,null,"Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["NE-4","Connection to Natural Heritage","To provide connections to nature and green spaces to benefit human health through proxmity or access, and to minimize the amount of the natural heritage that is backlotted by residential development.","Yes","Does your site contain or abut a natural heritage feature?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group MM","Good\n• Provide physical public connections (such as public access blocks, single loaded roads, parks, sidewalks, etc.) to 50% of the length of \n   the natural heritage system that abuts the proposed development (interface between development and natural heritage systems).\n\nGreat\n• Provide physical public connections (such as public access blocks, single loaded roads, parks, sidewalks, etc.) to 75% or more of the \n   length of the natural heritage system that abuts the proposed development (interface between development and natural heritage \n   systems).",null,{"$f":"IF(R54=\"Good\",2,IF(R54=\"Great\",4,0))","v":0},null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
[null,null,null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group MM",null,null,null,null,null,"Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["NE-5","Natural Heritage System Enhancements","To improve natural heritage system, particularly with respect to wildlife habitat and/or ecological functions.","Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group NN","Good\n• Provide and implement Woodland Management Plan within and/or abutting the subject lands, where not already required by the \n   municipality.",null,{"$f":"IF(R56=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options. Confirm with municipal partners if there is agreement that 10 points are available for this Metric."]
[null,"Natural Heritage System Enhancements",null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group OO","Good\n• Provide and implement an Invasive Species Management Plan for a natural heritage feature, where not already required by the \n   municipality.",null,{"$f":"IF(R57=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
[null,"Natural Heritage System Enhancements",null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group PP","Good\n• Provide habitat structure(s) for species at risk, such as bird structures, butterfly boxes, and hibernaculum.",null,{"$f":"IF(R58=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
[null,"Natural Heritage System Enhancements",null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group QQ","Great\n• Provide a form of natural heritage restoration/enhancement that provides a net ecological gain, above municipal requirements.",null,{"$f":"IF(R59=\"Great\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
[null,"Natural Heritage System Enhancements",null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Excellent",5,null,"Group RR","Excellent\n• Design and deliver a linear continuous/uninterrupted naturalized corridor, not already identified as a natural heritage feature in the Official \n   Plan or through technical studies, which creates a functional linkage between at least two natural heritage features.\n",null,{"$f":"IF(R60=\"Excellent\",5,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","I think all the Natural Heritage Enhancements will have to be separate \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
["NE-6","Supporting Pollinators","To provide landscape materials that support and provide habitat for pollinators (e.g. birds, bees, butterflies). Without pollinators, much of the food we eat and the natural habitats we enjoy would not exist. Pollinators are under increasing stress due to habitat loss, invasive species, diseases, pesticides, and climate change.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group SS","Good\n• Native plants that support pollinators make up 25% of total quantity of plants proposed on the landscape plan.\n\nGreat\n• Native plants that support pollinators make up 50% of the total quantity of plants proposed on the landscape plan.",null,{"$f":"IF(R61=\"Good\",1,IF(R61=\"Great\",2,0))","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",1,null,"Group SS",null,null,null,null,null,"Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["NE-7","Dedicated Fruit/Vegetable Garden Space","To promote grown food, improve physical and mental wellbeing, and to encourage social interaction.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group TT","Good\n\n• For multi-unit residential developments:\n      • Provide garden space that is equal to 25 square metres (or 250 square feet) or 5% of the rooftop amenity area or 5% ground floor\n        landscaped area (whichever is greater).\n      • Provide a shed for gardening equipment storage.\n      • Provide a water source for the garden space. \n\nFor ground-oriented residential developments:\n• With yards\n      • For each residential lot, provide a raised garden bed that is at least 12 inches (30 centimetres) tall, 4 inches (1.2 metres) wide, and \n        6 feet (1.8 metres) long. \n• Without yards\n      • For each unit, provide container gardens that can accommodate 15 gallons (57 litres) of soil and are at least 12 inches (30 \n        centimetres) deep.",null,{"$f":"IF(R63=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist","should not apply to ICIs\n\nLikley need three separate entries for the Scoring Tool: (1) Multi-res, (2) low rise with a yard, and (3) low rise without a yard. These will then be \"Yes\" or \"No\" options."]
["NE-8","Park Access","To promote visual and physical access to public parks and to make it easier for people of all ages and abilities to integrate physical activity and social interaction as part of their daily activity.","Yes","Does your proposal include or abut any parks?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",3,null,"Group UU","Good\n• Provide 2 or more road frontages for each park (e.g. urban square, parkette, and neighborhood park).\n\nGreat\n• Provide 3 or more road frontages for all parks. \n",null,{"$f":"IF(R64=\"Good\",3,IF(R64=\"Great\",6,0))","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer"]
[null,null,null,"Yes",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group UU",null,null,null,null,null,"Urban Designer"]
["NE-9","Stormwater Quantity and Balance","To support a treatment-train approach to stormwater management, emphasizing source and conveyance controls to promote infiltration, evaporation, and/or re-use of runoff and/or rainwater. Managing stromwater at the early stages of the treatment-train can provide more resilient communities and reduce risks of downstream flooding and erosion.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group VV","Good\n• Retain runoff volume from the 10 millimetres rainfall event on public and private sites.\n\nGreat\n• Retain runoff volume from the 15 millimetres rainfall event on public and private sites.\n\nExcellent\n• Retain runoff volume from the 25 millimetres rainfall event on public and private sites.",null,{"$f":"IF(R66=\"Good\",2,IF(R66=\"Great\",4,IF(R66=\"Excellent\",7,0)))","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group VV",null,null,null,null,null,"Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Excellent",3,null,"Group VV",null,null,null,null,null,"Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
["NE-10","Stormwater Quality","To protect receiving water bodies from water quality degradation that may result from development and urbanization. Controlling the quality of stormwater can provide for improved quality of receiving water bodies, resulting in fewer algae blooms, longer swimming seasons, and a variety of other other ecological benefits.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group WW","Good\n• Remove over 80% of TSS (Total Suspended Solids) from all runoff leaving the site during a 25 millimetre rainfall event (based on the \n   post-development level of imperviousness).\n\nGreat\n• Remove over 90% of TSS from all runoff leaving the site during a 25 millimetre rainfall event (based on the post-development level of \n   imperviousness).",null,{"$f":"IF(R69=\"Good\",1,IF(R69=\"Great\",5,0))","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",4,null,"Group WW",null,null,null,null,null,"Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
["NE-12","Multi-purpose Stormwater Management","To enhance the public use value of these facilities.","Yes","Does your proposal include a stormwater management pond?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group ZZ","Good\n• Introduce beautification measures/amenities that beautify stormwater management ponds (e.g. public art, interpretive signage).",null,{"$f":"IF(R71=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"No","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["INFRASTRUCTURE AND BUILDINGS (IB)"]
["IB-1","Buildings Designed and/or Certified under Accredited \"Green\" Rating System\n(Single third-party certification)","To recognize leadership and efforts to achieve independent third-party green certification systems that demonstrates high sustainability performance. Sustainability certification systems provide recognizable and verified certifications demonstrating to the public a high degree of sustainability performance is being achieved.","No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",7,null,"Group AAA","Good\n• Includes 1 to 7 green buildings enrolled in one or more recognized third party standards. 1 to 7 available points (1 point per building, \n   total 7 points available).\n\nFor the performance target, select the number of buildings enrolled in a recognized third-party green rating system as listed in the Guidebook (maximum of 7).",null,{"$f":"R73","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","One point per building, up to seven points; confirm this is filtered out by OBC metrics requirement\n\nthe Green Rating System performance targets will all need to be separate."]
[null,"Buildings Designed and/or Certified under Accredited \"Green\" Rating System\n(Multiple third-party certifications)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Excellent",7,null,"Group AAA","Excellent\n• If a building is registered for more than one green rating system certification (1 additional point per building).\n\nFor the performance target, select the number of buildings enrolled in more than one recognized third-party green rating system as listed in the Guidebook (maximum of 7).",null,{"$f":"R74","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","One point per building, up to seven points.\nConfirm with municipal partners if this allows for 14 total points if 7 or more buildings have more than one certification system."]
[null,"Buildings Designed and/or Certified under Accredited \"Green\" Rating System\n(LEED ND)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group BBB","• The development will achieve LEED ND v4. The performance target is 'Yes' or 'No'.",null,{"$f":"IF(R75=\"Yes\",2,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","If this is captured in base/bronze score, then should we increase this to great target? LEED ND is duplication of metrics in many ways"]
[null,"Buildings Designed and/or Certified under Accredited \"Green\" Rating System\n(One Planet Living)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Excellent",4,null,"Group CCC","• The development will achieve One Planning Living rating. The performance target is 'Yes' or 'No'.",null,{"$f":"IF(R76=\"Yes\",4,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","Confirm with municipal partners if LEED ND is additional 2 points (possible total of 16 points) and OPL is additional 4 points (total of 20 points), or additional points from OPL allows for total of 18 points."]
["IB-6","Embodied Carbon of Building Materials: Material Efficient Framing","To increase the growing awareness of the importance of addressing the embodied carbon and other GHG emissions associated with building materials.","Yes","Does your proposal include a building of less than six storeys?",null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group GGG","Great\n• For all lowrise wood-framed construction, use at least 3 of the following advanced framing measures will be use:\n      • Pre-cut framing packages\n      • Engineered Floor Joist\n      • Single Top-Plates\n      • Two Stud Corners\n      • Stud spacing greater than 406 mm (16”) on any storey,\n      • Ceiling joist spacing greater than 406 mm (16”) on any storey,\n      • Floor joist spacing greater than 406 mm (16”) on any storey. All corners have no more than 2 studs.",null,{"$f":"IF(R77=\"Great\",3,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner"]
["IB-10","Solar Readiness\n(1st of 2 categories for available points)","To encourage the use of renewable energy and reduce reliance on fossil fuel-based energy. Solar energy can provide cost-effective methods to reduce energy use and will have strong climate change benefits.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Good\n• For greenfield sites that provide ground-oriented development, 100% of dwellings in the project are designed for solar readiness.",null,{"$f":"IF(R78=\"Good\",3,0)","v":0},null,"Yes"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group MMM","Great\n• All buildings in the project are designed for solar readiness.",null,{"$f":"IF(R79=\"Great\",3,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","Should this be a \"Good\" target? Keep as \"Great\" if already coded that way in the Brampton scoring tool."]
[null,"Solar Readiness\n(2nd of 2 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",2,null,"Group NNN","Great\n• 1% of the total energy is generated on-site by renewable energy sources.\n\nExcellent\n• More than 1% of the total energy is generated on-site by renewable energy sources, up to 5%. (1 additional point per percent increase \n   up to 5 additional points)",null,{"$f":"IF(R80=\"1% of the total energy\",2,IF(R80=\"Greater than 1% but less than 2%\",3,IF(R80=\"Greater than 2% but less than 3%\",4,IF(R80=\"Greater than 3% but less than 4%\",5,IF(R80=\"Greater than 4% but less than 5%\",6,IF(R80=\"5% or more of the total energy\",7,0))))))","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","The \"Great\" score may need to start at 3 points."]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Excellent",1,null,"Group NNN",null,null,null,null,null,"Development Planner"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Good",3,null,"Group OOO",null,null,null,null,null,"Development Planner","Need Metric Qualifier for low rise"]
["IB-11","Energy Strategy\n(1st of 2 categories for available points)","To encourage the early consideration and incorporation of sustainable design features in the planning process relating to improved building energy efficiency, carbon reduction, and resilience, as well as to take advantage of district-scale opportunities in the case of multi-building developments.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group PPP","Great\n• Develop an Energy Strategy for the proposed development which includes the following as applicable:\n      • High-level energy analysis using archetype modelling or benchmarking data to estimate the overall energy consumption and GHG \n        emissions associated with the development.\n      • Identify and evaluate opportunities to reduce energy use intensity (EUI) and greenhouse gas emissions intensity (GHG) emissions \n        intensities down to a net-zero ready level of performance (e.g. the Excellent Target) through various measures such as more \n        efficient building form and massing, orientation, improved building envelope performance, highly efficient HVAC systems, heat \n        recovery, and lighting solutions. \n      • Analysis of low-carbon energy solutions and on-site renewable energy generation potential that can be incorporated into the \n        development, such as rooftop photovoltaic (PV), geo-exchange systems, high-efficiency combined heat and power (CHP), thermal \n        energy stores, and sewer water heat recovery. \n      • Identify and evaluate opportunities for backing power systems and passive design features that will improve the resilience of \n        buildings to area-wide power outages.\n• For multi-unit development, also conduct the following:\n      • In the case of multi-building development proposals or in intensification areas identified by the municipality, investigate the feasibility \n        of shared energy solutions such as the development of low-carbon thermal energy networks or connection to planned or existing \n        district energy systems, and identify the required provisions to be district energy-ready.",null,{"$f":"IF(R83=\"Great\",3,0)","v":0},null,"No","Environmental Planner","Confirm scoring with municipal partners and Guidebook. Guidebook notes 6 ponts for Energy Strategy and additional 6 points for commitment to lower EUI (yet says total of 11 points)."]
[null,"Energy Strategy\n(2nd of 2 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Excellent",6,null,"Group PPP","Excellent\n• In addition to developing an Energy Strategy, commit to meeting an energy use intensity (EUI) and greenhouse gas emissions intensity \n   (GHGI) target for the site that strives towards a near-net zero emissions level of performance as agreed upon with the City.\n• Develop a zero-carbon transition plan that lays out the pathway towards achieving carbon neutrality in the future through a variety of \n   design measures, such as providing the necessary infrastructure for full building electrification and avoidance of on-site combustion of \n   fossil fuels.",null,{"$f":"IF(R84=\"Excellent\",6,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Environmental Planner"]
["IB-12","Building Energy Efficiency, Greenhouse Gas Reduction, and Resilience\n\nPart 9 Residential Buildings (3 storeys or less and less than 600 m2 in gross floor area).","To promote buildings that are designed to be energy-efficient with reduced operating costs and greenhouse gas emissions associated with building operations, while improving the thermal comfort of occupants and enhancing building resilience. Well-designed buildings that are energy-efficient can improve indoor and outdoor air quality and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. [Select from one of the three building types]","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Great",6,null,"Group RRR","Design, construct and certify (or label) to:",null,{"$f":"IF(R85=\"Design to EnergyStar V17\",3,IF(R85=\"EnergyStar V17 Certified\",7,IF(R85=\"CHBA Net Zero Ready Certified\",13,IF(R85=\"CHBA Net Zero Certified or Passive House Certified\",21,0))))","v":0},null,"Yes","Environmental Planner","Update performance targets in the Guidebook to reflect the Council endorsement of a pathway to net zero energy buildings."]
[null,"Building Energy Efficiency, Greenhouse Gas Reduction, and Resilience\n\nPart 3 Buildings – Multi-Unit Residential, Office and \nRetail (more than 3 storeys or more than 600 m2 in gross floor area).",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Excellent",10,null,"Group SSS","Develop a whole building energy model, and design and construct the building to achieve the following whole building performance metrics:",null,{"$f":"IF(R86=\"TEUI between 170 to 136; TEDI between 70 to 51; GHGI between 20 to 16\",3,IF(R86=\"TEUI between 135 to 101; TEDI between 50 to 31; GHGI between 15 to 11\",7,IF(R86=\"TEUI between 100 to 76; TEDI between 30 to 16; GHGI between 10 to 6\",13,IF(R86=\"TEUI of 75 or less; TEDI of 15 or less; GHGI of 5 or less\",21,0))))","v":0},null,"Yes","Environmental Planner"]
[null,"Building Energy Efficiency, Greenhouse Gas Reduction, and Resilience\n\nAll Other Part 3 Buildings",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"All Other Part 3 Buildings\nDevelop a whole-building energy model, and design and construct the building to achieve the following improvements in energy efficiency over the Ontario Building Code (OBC) SB-10, Division 3 (2017) reference building.",null,{"$f":"IF(R87=\"15% improvement over OBC\",3,IF(R87=\"25% improvement over OBC\",7,IF(R87=\"37% improvement over OBC\",13,IF(R87=\"50% improvement over OBC\",21,0))))","v":0},null,"Yes"]
[null,"Building Energy Efficiency, GHG Reduction, and Resilience\n\nCommissioning\n(1st of 3 additional categories for available points)","To promote buildings that are designed to be energy-efficient with reduced operating costs and greenhouse gas emissions associated with building operations, while improving the thermal comfort of occupants and enhancing building resilience. Well-designed buildings that are energy-efficient can improve indoor and outdoor air quality and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group TTT","Great\n• Conduct best practice commissioning, per the requirements referenced in LEED BD+C v4 Fundamental Commissioning and \n   Verification pre-requisite.\n\n(Building commissioning is a systematic process of verifying that the various building sub-systems such as building envelope, mechanical (HVAC), plumbing and lighting systems are constructed and operational per the project requirements and design intent.)",null,{"$f":"IF(R88=\"Great\",3,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Environmental Planner"]
[null,"Building Energy Efficiency, GHG Reduction, and Resilience\n\nAir Tightness Testing\n(2nd of 3 additional categories for available points)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Excellent",4,null,"Group UUU","Excellent\n• Airtightness Testing\n• Conduct a whole-building air leakage test to improve the quality and airtightness of the building envelope",null,{"$f":"IF(R89=\"Excellent\",4,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Environmental Planner"]
[null,"Building Energy Efficiancy, GHG Reduction and Resilience\n\nConnection to Markham District Energy\n(3rd of 3 additional categories for available points)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Excellent\n• Connect to Markham District Energy (MDE)\n• MDE is implementing a plan to decarbonize its network, which will allow connected buildings to achieve lower greenhouse gas \n   emissions intentity (GHG)",null,{"$f":"IF(R90=\"Excellent\",4,0)","v":0},null,"Yes"]
["IB-13","Rainwater and Greywater Use","To reduce potable water use for interior building functions.","No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group WWW","Good\n• Rainwater or greywater is captured on-site and used for exterior uses (e.g. landscape irrigation).\n  • Buildings designed for rainwater and/or greywater use readiness (e.g. plumbing infrastructure rough-ins or dedicated cistern space for \n     rainwater or greywater use or greywater irrigation that may be connected in the future are included in the building).\n\nGreat\n• Greywater Use for Interior Functions\n  • Greywater is captured on site, treated, and used for toilet and urinal flushing, as well as priming flood drains within a home.\nOR\n• Rainwater Use for Interior Functions\n  • Rainwater is captured on site and used for toilet and urinal flushing.",null,{"$f":"IF(R91=\"Good\",1,IF(R91=\"Great\",4,0))","v":0},null,"Yes","Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
[null,null,null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group WWW",null,null,null,null,null,"Landscape Architect / Technologist"]
["IB-14","Back-Up Power\n\n(Rough-ins - 1st of 3 categories for available points)","To encourage the provision of back-up power that enables the functioning of key utilities/building functions during power failures resulting from extreme weather events.","No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group XXX","Good\n• Provide rough-ins to allow for the installation of external generators/auxiliary power supply at a later date.",null,{"$f":"IF(R93=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner"]
[null,"Back-Up Power\n\n(Refuge area - 2nd of 3 categories for available points)",null,"Yes","Does your proposal contain a multi unit building?",null,"Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Yes","Good",1,null,"Group YYY","Good\n• For mid-rise and high-rise buildings, provide a refuge area with heating, cooling, lighting, potable water, and power available for 72 \n   hours.",null,{"$f":"IF(R94=\"Good\",1,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner"]
[null,"Back-Up Power\n\n(72 hrs of back-up power - 3rd of 3 categories for available points)",null,"No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Great",3,null,"Group ZZZ","Great\n• Provide 72 hours of back-up power to essential building systems.",null,{"$f":"IF(R95=\"Great\",3,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","Need Metric Qualifier for midrise and highrise"]
["IB-15","Extreme Wind Protection for Ground-Oriented Development","To increase the resistance of homes to the impacts of high wind events, and make them more resilience to the impacts of climate change.","No",null,"OBC","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group AAAA","Good\n• Roof to Wall Connections:\n• Tie roof rafters, roof trusses or roof joists to load-bearing wall framing in a manner that will resist a factored uplift load of 3 kN. This \n   measure requires adequate connection of the top plate to the supporting wall studs, combined with adequate continuous vertical load \n   path. If continuous structural wall sheathing (see Measure A.2.3) is not applied, then a top-to-bottom inspection to address all potential \n   weak links in the continuous vertical load path using additional tires, straps or related measures should be applied.\nAND\n• When engineered connectors are used, builders should request that truss manufacturers supply appropriate roof-to-wall connections \n   along with trusses.\n\n• Stud to Sill Plate Connection\n• Installation of metal straps or connectors to connect lower storey wall studs to the sill plate.",null,{"$f":"IF(R96=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Development Planner","Need Metric Qualifier for low rise"]
["IB-18","Bird-Friendly Design","To reduce the incidents of bird collisions and provide an urban environment where birds can thrive. The built environment can have strong negative impacts on birds. Design and system selection can result in fewer bird collisions and deaths.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group EEEE","Good\n• A combination of Bird-Friendly Design strategies on at least 85% of contiguous glass area greater than 2 square metres within the first \n  16 metres of the building above-grade (including interior courtyards) and above green roofs is applied. \nAND\n• The remaining 15% of glazed windows do not need to be treated unless the glazing is larger than 2 square metres or in close proximity \n   to open spaces, a green roof or a natural heritage feature.\n\n• Bird-Friendly Design Strategies may include: \n      • Visual patterns on glass,\n      • Window films,\n      • Fenestration patterns,\n      • Angled glass downwards,\n      • Reducing night sky lighting.\n      • Visual markers provided on the glass of proposed buildings with spacing no greater than 10 centimetres x 10 centimetres.",null,{"$f":"IF(R97=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"No","Urban Designer","Need Metric Qualifier for mid and high rise residential and ICI"]
[null,"Bird-Friendly Design\n(Subdivisions)",null,"No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Good",2,null,"Group FFFF","Good\n• For Subdivisions, apply Bird-Friendly Design strategies for ground-oriented residential development that is adjacent to natural heritage \n   systems and open spaces.",null,{"$f":"IF(R98=\"Good\",2,0)","v":0},null,"Yes","Urban Designer","Need Metric Qualifier for low rise next to natural heritage\n\nWhat are bird-friendly design strategies for ground related adjacent to natural heritage?"]
["INNOVATION (IN)"]
["I-1 ","Innovation","To encourage applicants to achieve innovative performance. Innovation strategies must demonstrate a comprehensive approach, have significant, measurable environmental benefits, and be better than standard practice.","No",null,null,"Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Exceptional",10,null,"Group KKKK","Exceptional\nUp to a total of 10 points based on the measurable sustainability benefit provided (additional points be awarded at the discretion of the municipality).\n",null,null,"Other",null,"Other","Point value is determined on a case by case basis\nMaximum point value that could be awarded is 10 points"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Final Score:",{"$f":"SUM(S14:S100)","v":0}]

{"sheet":"IB-12 Targets","index":2,"n_rows":16,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":16,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["THIS WORKSHEET WILL BE HID OR LOCKED"]
[]
["IB-12 Target Description"]
[null,null,null,null,null,"OTHER PART 3 BUILDINGS"]
[null,"Total Energy Use Intensity (TEUI)","Thermal Energy Demand Intensity (TEDI)"," Greenhouse Gas Emissions Intensity (GHGI)"]
[null,"(kWh/m2/yr)","(kWh/m2/yr)","(kgCO2/m2/yr)",null,null,"GOOD","15% improvement in energy efficiency "]
["GOOD",170,70,20,null,null,"GREAT","25% improvement in energy efficiency "]
["GREAT",135,50,15,null,null,"EXCELLENT","37% improvement in energy efficiency "]
["EXCELLENT",100,30,10,null,null,"EXCEPTIONAL","50% improvement in energy efficiency "]
["EXCEPTIONAL",75,15,5]
[null,null,null,null,null,"PART 9 LOW RISE RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"GOOD","Design to EnergyStar V17"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"GREAT","EnergyStar V17 Certified"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"EXCELLENT","CHBA Net Zero Ready Certified"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"EXCEPTIONAL","CHBA Net Zero Certified or Passive House Certified"]

{"sheet":"DropDownLists","index":3,"n_rows":241,"n_cols":17,"rows_kept":241,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["Document","Typical Verifier","THIS WORKSHEET WILL BE HID OR LOCKED",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"TEUI","TEDI","GHGI",null,"Other Part 3 Buildings"]
["Metric BE-1/M-3","Development Planner",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"kW/m2/yr","kW/m2/yr","KgCO2/m2/yr"]
[null,"Urban Designer","Yes","Good",null,null,"Good","1%",null,"EnergyStar V17 Certified",null,null,"170 to 136","70 to 51","20 to 16",null,"15% improvement over OBC"]
["Planning Justification Report","Urban Design Landscape / Streetscape Reviewers","No","Great",null,null,"Excellent","2%",null,"CHBA Net Zero Ready Certified",null,null,"135 to 101","50 to 31","15 to 11",null,"25% improvement over OBC"]
["Urban Design Brief","Development Planner",null,"Excellent",null,null,null,"3%",null,"CHBA Net Zero Certified",null,null,"100 to 76","30 to 16","10 to 6",null,"37% improvement over OBC"]
["Other","Heritage Planner",null,"Exceptional",null,null,null,"4%",null,"Passive House Certified",null,null,"75 or less","15 or less","5 or less",null,"50% improvement over OBC"]
[null,"Environmental Planner",null,null,null,null,null,"5% or Higher"]
["Metric BE-2/M-4","Environmental Engineer / Technologist"]
[null,"Transportation Planner / Traffic Planning Technologist",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"TEUI between 170 to 136; TEDI between 70 to 51; GHGI between 20 to 16"]
["Draft Plan of Subdivision","Policy Planner",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"TEUI between 135 to 101; TEDI between 50 to 31; GHGI between 15 to 11"]
["Site Plan","Operations Staff",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"TEUI between 100 to 76; TEDI between 30 to 16; GHGI between 10 to 6"]
["Other","Other",null,"Metric BE-4/BE-10/M-6/NE-2/NE-5",null,null,"Metric IB-1: Green Rating Systems",null,null,null,null,null,"TEUI of 75 or less; TEDI of 15 or less; GHGI of 5 or less"]
[]
["Metric BE-3",null,null,"Excellent",null,null,1]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,2,null,null,null,null,null,"Design to EnergyStar V17"]
["Planning Justification Report",null,null,"Metric BE-5/NE-5/IB-11/IB-12",null,null,3,null,null,null,null,null,"EnergyStar V17 Certified"]
["Draft Plan of Subdivision",null,null,null,null,null,4,null,null,null,null,null,"CHBA Net Zero Ready Certified"]
["Site Plan",null,null,"Great",null,null,5,null,null,null,null,null,"CHBA Net Zero Certified or Passive House Certified"]
["Other",null,null,null,null,null,6]
[null,null,null,"Excellent",null,null,7]
["Metric BE-4"]
[]
["Planning Justification Report",null,null,"Metric IB-5, IB-8",null,null,"Metric IB-10"]
["Community Design Guidelines"]
["Other",null,null,"Great",null,null,"1% of the total energy"]
[null,null,null,"Excellent",null,null,"Greater than 1% but less than 2%"]
["Metric BE-5",null,null,null,null,null,"Greater than 2% but less than 3%"]
[null,null,null,"Metric NE-3/IB-6/IB-8/IB-9/IB-10/IB-14",null,null,"Greater than 3% but less than 4%"]
["Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment",null,null,null,null,null,"Greater than 4% but less than 5%"]
["Heritage Conservation Plan",null,null,"Great",null,null,"5% or more of the total energy"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric BE-6/BE-7/IB-7"]
[]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric BE-8"]
[]
["Transportation Impact Study"]
["Transportation Demand Management Plan"]
["Site Plan"]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric BE-9-IB-3"]
[]
["Site Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric BE-10"]
[]
["Site Plan"]
["Floor Plans"]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-1"]
[]
["Draft Plan of Subdivision"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-2"]
[]
["Planning Justification Report"]
["Draft Plan of Subdivision"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-5"]
[]
["Elevation Drawings"]
["Floor Plans"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-6"]
[]
["Site Plan"]
["Floor Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-7/M-8"]
[]
["Transportation Impact Study"]
["Transportation Demand Management Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric M-9"]
[]
["Transportation Impact Study"]
["Transportation Demand Management Plan"]
["Urban Design Brief"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-1"]
[]
["Arborist Report/Tree Inventory Preservation Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-2"]
[]
["Soil Volume Plans"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-3/NE-6/NE-7/IB-13"]
[]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-4"]
[]
["Draft Plan of Subdivision"]
["Site Plan"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-5"]
[]
["Environmental Impact Study"]
["Woodlot Management Plan"]
["Natural Heritage Restoration Plan"]
["Invasive Species Management Plan"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-8"]
[]
["Urban Design Brief"]
["Site Plan"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-9/NE-10"]
[]
["Functional Servicing Report"]
["Stormwater Management Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-11"]
[]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Planting Plans"]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric NE-12"]
[]
["Functional Servicing Report"]
["Stormwater Management Plan"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-1"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Signed Partnership Agreement"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-2"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Site Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-4/IB-6/IB-10/IB-15"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-5"]
[]
["Site Plan"]
["Life Cycle Assessment Report"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-8"]
[]
["Elevation Drawings"]
["Roof Plans"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-9"]
[]
["Elevation Drawings"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-11"]
[]
["Energy Strategy Report"]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-12"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Energy Model Report"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-14"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Floor Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-16"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Electrical and Mechanical Single Line Diagrams"]
["Metering Plan"]
["Other"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-17"]
[]
["Elevation Drawings"]
["Landscape Plans"]
["Photometric Plans"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-18"]
[]
["Elevation Drawings"]
["Other"]
[]
["Letter of Commitment"]
["Other"]
[]
["Metric IB-19"]
[]
["Site Plan"]
["Floor Plans"]
["Other"]